|
australian ageing agenda

Wide support for euthanasia: poll

Published on Thu, 06/12/2012, 04:16:15

|

By Natasha Egan

More than four in five Australian adults support reform of voluntary euthanasia laws and almost a quarter of would change their vote if their usual election candidate opposed reform, according to a poll commissioned by advocacy organization YourLastRight.com

The Newspoll run survey, which questioned over 2500 adults across Australia, also found that legalising voluntary euthanasia ranked third in importance among national policy issues.

 YourLastRight.com CEO Neil Francis said the number of Australians supporting voluntary euthanasia has increased significantly since 2007.

“The overwhelming majority of voters have been in favour of legal assisted dying for the last 40 years,” he said in a statement.

Doctor assisted suicide

Source: Neil Francis, YourLastRight.com

Nationally, 82 per cent of respondents agreed a doctor should provide a lethal dose if requested by a “hopelessly ill patient, experiencing unrelievable suffering, with absolutely no chance of recovering” while 13 per cent said disagreed.

The most support was in Victoria where 86 per cent of respondents supported it compared to 11 per cent who didn’t. 

The least support came from Tasmania where 78 per cent gave their support to a doctor providing a lethal dose in that particular circumstance compared to 17 per cent who didn’t.

“It is important to demonstrate to our political representatives – and they are supposed to be our representatives – that continued blocking and stonewalling of responsible, properly-regulated assisted dying is flouting the active wishes of the overwhelming majority of their constituents,” Mr Francis said.

It’s a vote changer

Source: Neil Francis, YourLastRight.com

According to the poll, 23 per cent of Australians would change their vote if their usual election candidate opposed voluntary euthanasia law reform compared to 6 per cent who said they would change their vote if their usual election candidate advocated for it.

For a usual candidate who opposes reform, this sentiment was strongest amongst Greens voters (32 per cent) and weakest for Liberal/National party voters (15 per cent).

The reverse was also true for a usual candidate advocating voluntary euthanasia law reform with the feeling strongest for Liberal/National party voters (7 per cent) and weakest amongst Greens voters (4 per cent).

While politicians may have their own deeply held personal views and beliefs about assisted dying they have to recognise that they aren’t in office to represent themselves only, Mr Francis said.

“With Victorian, South Australian, and Federal elections stacking up before the end of next year, I would counsel thoughtful politicians and their leaders to take account of this research’s third major finding: that candidates who oppose this reform will lose many more votes than those that support it,” said Mr Francis.

Important policy issue

Source: Neil Francis, YourLastRight.com - positive percentages reflect respondents choosing 'very important' or 'somewhat important' and negative percentages reflect respondents choosing 'not very important' or 'not at all important'

Respondents were asked to rate whether eight national policy issues were very important, somewhat important, not very important, or not at all important to them personally.

On the issue of ‘whether voluntary euthanasia is legalised’, 80 per cent of respondents said it was either very important or somewhat important to them personally while 17 per cent said it was either not very important or not at all important.

The issue ranked third in importance overall behind a national disability insurance scheme and dealing with asylum seeker boat arrivals. 

In order of personal importance, the issue of leagalising voluntary euthanasia was followed by policy relating to abortion, the death penalty, the national broadband network, a carbon tax or emissions trading scheme and same-sex marriage.

Voluntary euthanasia is not a part of palliative care

While having no specific comment on this particular poll, Palliative Care Australia (PCA) CEO Dr Yvonne Luxford, said there was a range of views in the Australian community about the ethical issue of the deliberate ending of life for a person living with a terminal condition. 

“Much community interest in euthanasia and physician assisted suicide is sparked by a need for assurance that pain and suffering will be relieved and that individual end of life decisions will be respected,” she said in a PCA position statement.

PCA’s position is that euthanasia and physician assisted suicide are not part of palliative care practice. 

“Informed discussion about euthanasia and physician assisted suicide is hindered by society’s failure to guarantee access to quality care at the end of life,” Dr Luxford said.

“Dying is a natural part of life, and declining or withdrawing aspects of treatment is acceptable if it aligns with the informed wishes of the patient. This does not constitute euthanasia or physician assisted suicide.”

Dying may be a natural part of life, but it can be a very traumatic end, even in palliative care. My father died of stomach cancer in one of the best palliative care facilities in Australia. He did not eat for the last six weeks of his life. Although he didn't have severe pain, he suffered terribly. He had overwhelming weakness, agitation, oral thrush and no control over basic bodily functions. He was totally wretched. He asked repeatedly for help to die, but was denied that right. Because he didn't have pain, he didn't get morphine, so he was conscious of his deterioration. He suffered to the end, and now my sister and I live with that final memory of his life. Anyone who goes through this would not support the current system. People shouldn't have to suffer at the end of life.
Posted by Sarah Edelman. 06/12/2012 08:07:13 PM
Neil's survey is all very nice, but the answers to those questions will understandably be more of an emotional knee-jerk reaction than anything else. Any change to the law needs to be well considered, hence the processes that are in place in parliaments. When you consider the scope for potential abuses (especially elder abuse), you can not possibly vote for what is essentially an exception to laws against murder. Besides, palliative care has the best drugs! :-)
Posted by John Fox. 06/12/2012 10:45:24 PM
“hopelessly ill patient, experiencing unrelievable suffering, with absolutely no chance of recovering” - in my eperience this is easily hypothesised but in reality, to define this the lines are incredibly blurry.
Posted by Jon Morrell. 07/12/2012 09:36:55 AM
Surveys can achieve any response if they frame the question right! There is no reason to suffer intractable pain Do people want pain relief and are afraid they they will not get it? Very different issue
Posted by Rhonda Nay. 07/12/2012 10:24:36 AM
The knowledge that voluntary euthanasia is available should someone need it in the future not only provides comfort when someone is in their final stage of dying, but can also provide mental piece of mine for years. For decades. I had a serious cancer and neurological disease diagnosis 15 years ago when I was 31 and am left with horrific and untreatable symptoms. And I'm definately getting worse over time. I used to fear aging because I'm at a higher risk of cancer and dementia recurrence, as well as a stroke. But the knowledge that I won't have to suffer horrifically in my dying stage if VE is legalised has given me such peace of mind ...... for decades. Quite literally. But the politicians continue to ignore the majority of Australians that support the legalisation of VE. Aren't they supposed to be acting for what WE want, not what they want?
Posted by y0lan. 10/12/2012 12:42:27 AM
I have areas' of my brain in a dementia state due to vascular tiny strokes... recently another degenerative dissabilitating diagnosis of spasmodic torticollis due to the deep part of my brain in cell death. I am 66yrs now diagnosed with two types of fementia t 62yrs.... Ishared with my father through his dementia and into his final days. Then my Uncle... dying in the same manner. It was such trauma for my sister and I. We claimed suicide of ourselves IF we had to endure such a death. Now I am faceds in it.... Already DRs are trying to manage mySymptoms and with the troticollis also "hell" already. symptoms "without much success" of quaility of life. I strongly believe, as animals we should have the right to end our lives.. when no more can be done towards saving it or giving us back quaility of life..... One having to starve themselves or reguse liquid, etc All the given Pallative care provisons.... are cruel and unjust... Terminal and in the last stages of in the dying procewss.... Dr supervised Euthanasia IS the only compassionat option. Carol Cronk.. Praying... Euthanasia for us all who so want and expect it should be our human rights.
Posted by Carol Cronk. 10/12/2012 01:28:50 PM
From some of the responses here, there seems to be continued misunderstanding. Some important points: * Palliative Care Australia themselves acknowledge that not all intolerable suffering at the end of life can be relieved, even with the best care. * Not everyone wants to be drugged up at the end of life. Many drugs have very unpleasant side effects, too. * The empirical research published in the scientific literature shows clearly that in proper, regulated arrangements, the "slippery slope" does not occur. And there is plenty of scope for "abuse" to occur right now: it is already legal to refuse life-saving medical treatment (we don't see suggestions that relatives will inappropriately influence in favour of that refusal), and it is legal to refuse food and fluids in order to die (which some will find dignified but others will abhor). All of that can occur without multiple medical opinions, a requirement to be well informed about what medicine and palliative care can offer, a requirement for clinicians to specifically consider the mental competence of the patient to make such decisions, formal requests in writing, a cooling off period, reporting of statistics to Parliament for policy oversight, and so on: a suite of checks and protections to be put in place under assisted dying law reform. * YourLastRight.com is transparent about its research and the methodology uses to collect data. Some researchers are not so transparent. The research was conducted by respected national pollster Newspoll under full professional standards. And, it can be noted that ALL research in recent times has found an overwhelming majority of Australians in favour of assisted dying law reform, including research sponsored by those opposed to it.
Posted by Neil Francis. 11/12/2012 09:49:20 AM
Add your own comment
4,216




subscribe to free e-news




MOST POPULAR ARTICLES


CONFERENCES & EVENTS
LASA Victoria State Congress & Exhibition 2013

Thursday 20 - Friday 21 June 2013, Flemington Racecourse. The LASA Victoria State Congress & Exhibition is back by popular demand in 2013 after a SOLD OUT State Congress in 2012.

Wed 03/04/2013 12:08:45 / Read More »
2nd Annual Aged Care Training

26th & 27th June 2013, L'Aqua, Cockle Bay Wharf, Sydney. This conference will examine strategies for strengthening quality and meeting future needs of aged care training under the current regulatory reform.

Tue 19/03/2013 03:21:34 / Read More »
NIMAC Conference & Trade Exhibition 2013

The Nurses In Management Aged Care Conference & Trade Exhibition 2013 will be held at Jupiter's, Gold Coast from 4 - 5 July 2013. A full day Clinical Workshop will be held prior to the conference on Wednesday 3 July.

Tue 21/05/2013 02:43:45 / Read More »
7th Australasian Better Boards Conference

July 5,6, & 7, Melbourne Convention & Exhibition Centre. Focusing specifically on governance & leadership knowledge and guidance for leaders of Australasia’s non-profit organisations, the 7th Australasian Better Boards Conference will be held at the Mel

Wed 03/04/2013 05:11:06 / Read More »
HIC 2013

15 - 18 July 2013. Adelaide Convention Centre, North Terrace, Adelaide. HIC is Australia's most prestigious e-health event with a program that represents the cutting-edge in health informatics research and technology.

Fri 15/03/2013 08:48:27 / Read More »
Better Practice 2013

Better Practice conferences have an outstanding blend of industry experts and keynote speakers on relevant topics who will bring you practical advice on improving practical information about better practice ideas.

Wed 12/09/2012 02:40:57 / Read More »
Leadership in Quality Dementia care forum

24 July 2013. Melbourne Convention and Exhibition Centre, 1 Convention place, South Wharf 3000.

Thu 06/06/2013 03:59:07 / Read More »
The Wicking Symposium

2nd August. Ageing & Alzheimer’s Funding Outcomes in Research & Practice

Thu 06/06/2013 10:24:48 / Read More »
Marketing in a Consumer Directed Environment

24th & 25th September 2013, Rydges World Square, Sydney. Connecting providers directly to their clients.

Sun 09/06/2013 05:23:17 / Read More »
LASA National Congress 2013

5 - 7 August 2013, Sydney Convention & Exhibition Centre. Leading Age Services Australia (LASA) welcomes the age services industry to the networking event of 2013. Seek wisdom from Mark Bouris, Jon Dee & Todd Coates.

Fri 19/04/2013 08:42:34 / Read More »
Strengthening the Aged Care Workforce

21st & 22nd August, CQ Functions, Melbourne. The Strengthening Aged Care Workforce conference will explore the current workforce pressures and future needs of the aged care workforce.

Mon 13/05/2013 08:39:37 / Read More »
Residential Aged Care Delivery Models

18th & 19th September 2013, CQ Functions, Melbourne. Hear expert insights & case studies from 10 leading Residential Aged Care providers

Thu 30/05/2013 12:37:11 / Read More »

more conferences

EDUCATION & TRAINING
Clinical Governance in Aged Care

Have you ticked all the boxes for Clinical Governance including Risk, Safety & Quality in Aged Care facilities?

Fri 07/06/2013 03:40:56 / Read More »
Information systems - keys to delivering quality care

Make sure you have access to the right information at the right time for the right person.

Thu 06/06/2013 09:45:28 / Read More »
Foundations for managing risk in aged care

Risk management is everyone's responsibility.

Wed 03/10/2012 01:24:58 / Read More »
Making the most of complaints

"Complaints should be welcomed"

Wed 03/10/2012 01:33:55 / Read More »


HOT PRODUCTS

Ken Hands Agencies Insulated Meal Delivery Trolley

Our new Healthcare Meal Delivery Trolley is now available. This all stainless steel trolley will hold full meal trays (570 x 440mm) or 36 morning/afternoon tea tray (465 x 355mm).

Fri 14/06/2013 03:27:06 / Read More »

Prevention is better than care

Identify critical IT issues before they impact your care services with 24x7 monitoring.

Tue 14/08/2012 03:29:37 / Read More »

CoaguChek XS Plus

Compliance and effective monitoring...two essential components for optimizing oral anticoagulation therapy enabling quality of care.

Tue 03/04/2012 05:43:27 / Read More »
RESEARCH & CLINICAL NEWS

Ministers move to recognise pain as a chronic disease

Chronic pain costs the Australian economy an estimated $34 billion per year and is the nation's third most costly health problem. Now moves are underway to recognise pain as a chronic disease.

Thu 20/06/2013 07:24:53 / Read More »

Ageist labour market: report

National Seniors is calling on governments take the lead in changing ageist labour market attitudes following a new report which reveals high levels of real and perceived age-discrimination in the Australian labour market.

Thu 20/06/2013 03:19:24 / Read More »

Parkinson's treatment subsidised

A once-daily treatment patch for Parkinson's disease has been listed on the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme making it more readily available to the 60,000 Australians with the condition.

Tue 18/06/2013 04:27:51 / Read More »

Testosterone could combat dementia in women: study

Women on testosterone therapy perform better on cognitive tests, particularly in the areas of learning and memory, according to new research led by Monash University

Tue 18/06/2013 12:37:56 / Read More »

Research probes sexual assault of older women in care

Today marks World Elder Abuse Awareness day, an international event held to raise public attention of various forms of elder abuse and ways to prevent it. In Victoria, pioneering research is investigating how to prevent sexual assault of older women.

Fri 14/06/2013 07:19:23 / Read More »